Johnrob / Getty Images/iStockphoto
Commitment to Our Readers
GOBankingRates’ editorial team is dedicated to providing unbiased reviews and pertinent information. Utilizing data-driven methodologies, we evaluate financial products and services, ensuring our reviews and ratings are independent of advertiser influence. For deeper insights, explore our editorial guidelines and methodology for reviewing products and services.
20 Years
Helping You Live Richer
Expert Reviews for Informed Decisions
Trusted by
Millions of Readers
For many Americans, buying a home represents the most significant financial commitment they will ever make. Potential homebuyers often dedicate years to saving for a substantial down payment, hoping to turn their dream of homeownership into reality. However, purchasing an older home can sometimes transform that dream into a nightmare.
Similar to “lemon” cars, a “lemon” home refers to a property that has critical defects affecting its value, safety, or livability. Interestingly, certain states have a higher prevalence of these problematic properties.
Top States with High Risk of Lemon Homes
While lemon homes can appear anywhere, some states show a higher propensity for these properties. Common characteristics of lemon homes include their age and prevalent issues regarding plumbing, structure, electrical systems, and roofing, as noted by MovingPlace.
According to MovingPlace’s research, they assigned a lemon home risk score ranging from 0 to 100. Here are the top ten states where buyers are most likely to encounter lemon properties:
1. Rhode Island
2. Ohio
3. Massachusetts
4. Connecticut
5. Iowa
6. New York
7. Pennsylvania
8. Indiana
9. West Virginia
10. Michigan
Understanding the Context of Lemon Homes
Most lemon homes are found in the Rust Belt—a region known for its older housing stock and historical manufacturing presence. Notably, about 48% of homes across the U.S. date back to the 1980s or earlier, according to the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB). As of 2023, the median age of owner-occupied homes was recorded at 41 years, marking a ten-year increase since 2005.
Even with renovations made by sellers, cosmetic upgrades may only mask underlying problems. Although aesthetic improvements are valuable, they can conceal more extensive issues that could go unnoticed until after the sale. Additionally, many of these states are subject to harsh weather conditions, which can exacerbate property issues over time.
Avoiding the Lemon Home Pitfall
Conducting a home inspection is the most effective strategy for identifying a property’s problems pre-purchase. Yet, in competitive markets, buyers may choose to waive inspections. According to the National Association of Realtors, 21% of buyers opted out of home inspections as of September 2025.
Waiving home inspection contingencies poses significant risks for buyers. Although inspections may not uncover every issue, engaging a reliable inspector offers peace of mind by identifying any significant problems. It’s crucial to understand that home inspection regulations differ by state, as indicated by Zillow. Buyers must weigh the potential risks of skipping this essential step, particularly in light of the current economic challenges affecting many Americans.
While buying a home can be an exhilarating experience, acquiring a lemon property may quickly shift that excitement to anxiety regarding unforeseen financial repercussions.
